Moondrop Meteor VS MYER SL224

Youtube Video Summary

Moondrop Meteor arrives as a hybrid with one dynamic, two BA mids, and four treble planars, now priced around $550. The shell is massive but well-contoured resin with a flat 2-pin connector; fit can be good after some tip rolling, though the nozzle runs large. The stock cable feels cheap for the price and the accessory pack is underwhelming—no DAC, a basic case—so the unboxing doesn’t add much value.

Tonally this is a treble-focused set that sounds clean, clear, and crisp, with pleasing air and microdetail. Bass is the weak link: quantity and slam are light, leaving dynamics and note weight on the lean side; lower mids could be richer. Graphs show typical Moondrop-leaning tuning that sits close to target but wants ~2–3 dB more bass. It measures stable with impedance, which, paired with precise imaging and tidy staging (good, not “huge”), makes it a plausible studio monitor-style choice.

Against peers, Variations brings more energy and is the safer pick; Moondrop’s own Concerto and even Caden-line sets feel fuller down low. Cheaper rivals like EPZ P50 and AFUL P7 offer more fun, while HiSenior Mega 5 EST and Softears Volume S present stronger overall value and bass presence. Verdict: a solid, airy detail-getter with attractive aesthetics, but not an upgrade to bass-richer favorites; recommended on the used market or with a discount, and an easy skip at full MSRP if seeking warmth and impact.

Youtube Video Summary

Packaging overdelivers: a modular cable with 3.5/4.4/USB-C and an included dongle that gets loud enough, seven pairs of silicone tips plus foam, and a small zip case (nice but tight). The shell looks premium with a depth-effect faceplate and a metal nozzle (≈6.1 mm lip); fit is snug though potentially big for smaller ears. Build and accessories feel thoughtful at the price, with only a slightly rubbery cable texture to nitpick.

Tuning is a smooth, vocal-focused, meta-inspired balance: refined mids, a friendly yet detailed top end, and a clean, controlled low end. Bass quality is textured and separated but intentionally polite—not for hip-hop/EDM impact chasers. The midrange brings clear, natural tone without shout; both male and female vocals sit forward. The treble is the star: highly resolving, airy, and surprisingly non-fatiguing for the four micro-planars, avoiding metallic glare while adding tasteful sparkle.

Technically, separation and resolution impress, with a mild cohesiveness quirk where the treble detail outshines bass/mids. Versus peers: CK2V is more V-shaped and brighter-hot; SL224 sounds more natural. Moondrop Meteor offers smoother treble and mid timbre, but SL224’s bass quality and value punch back. Dunu Brain Dance is technically stronger; SL224 wins on tonality. SoftEars Studio 4 remains more lifelike/cohesive; SL224 brings more air and fun. AFUL Performer 7 is the better all-rounder; SL224 is for lighter-bass, vocal clarity. Kiwi Ears Astral is airier/more micro-detailed; SL224 plays it safer up top with more forward vocals. Recommendation: vocal lovers and treble-sensitive listeners wanting detail without sting. Not for bassheads or warm-tilted tastes. Final verdict: a confident 4/5 and the most compelling Myer release so far.

Youtube Video Summary

Moondrop’s new “flagship” Meteor lands with a decent first impression: a natural planar timbre that avoids the overly sizzly or peaky upper ranges found in rivals, and clean, forward vocals that shine on ballads at mid volume. The overall tuning sits neutral with a tilt toward female vocals, and technical performance is good—competitive but not class-leading at its bracket. Fit is on the thicker side with a quirky curve, so a demo is wise. The catch: the low end is tame to the point of feeling clinical, lacking slam, authority, and bass-guitar/drum texture in busier rock and metal. Treble is balanced with some extension, yet it lacks air and micro-nuance, making the presentation feel less special. Net result: more a side-grade to Dusk than an upgrade—and at $500+, that stings.

Energy genres expose more issues: the boosted 1–3 kHz pushes vocals shouty past ~60–65 dB and the set doesn’t scale well, especially with K-Pop/J-Pop and mainstream pop where even the Dusk can sound more engaging with better contrast and more low end. Value is the real problem: the EPZ P50 at roughly half the price brings more bass, more air, and similar accessories; competitors like IO Volare (4×EST), Oracle Mk1, or a sale-priced Variations offer smoother, airier treble, finer micro-detail, and better all-round balance. The Meteor’s use of micro-planars instead of ESTs, plus unchanged accessories (think Aria 2/Dusk level), makes the premium hard to justify. Overall, it edges sets like “Brain Dance/Damage” on timbre but gives up technicalities and versatility. Recommendation: skip—grab the P50, go IO Volare/Oracle/Variations, or EQ a Variations (fill the scoop, ease 1–2 kHz) for a result that outclasses Meteor. Bonus note: Moondrop’s new flagship Psyche also gets side-eyed—$2,000 without ESTs feels more cash-grab than value.

Youtube Video Summary

The $500 Moondrop Meteor packs an oversized 13mm dynamic driver for bass, two balanced armatures for mids, and four micro planar drivers for treble. Objectively, its frequency response is fantastic—neutral with a tasteful sub-bass lift and exceptionally smooth, reserved treble that avoids harshness. Vocals sound natural and forward without edginess, and high-frequency percussion retains realistic timbre. Build quality impresses with a glossy, semi-transparent shell and a unique "meteorite" side panel, though the bulky design compromises fit stability versus sleeker Moondrop models. Accessories feel recycled from cheaper offerings, including a basic case and functional but kink-prone swappable-termination cable.

Subjectively, however, the Meteor feels unengaging. Its bass lacks punch and definition despite the large driver, coming across as soft and undynamic. Combined with the relaxed treble, this results in a lackluster sense of separation, layering, and imaging—music sounds cohesive but lacks incisiveness and visceral impact. While tonally balanced, the presentation is overly cautious, missing the excitement expected at this price. Even Moondrop’s own $360 Dusk outperforms it with tighter bass, sharper imaging, and greater overall engagement.

Comparisons highlight its shortcomings. The Dunu DK-31BD offers superior bass impact and more expressive treble at the same price, while the HiSenior Mega5EST delivers better definition and layering despite a warmer tilt. Ultimately, the Meteor’s excellent tuning can’t compensate for its dull technical performance. It’s a competent monitor but fails to justify its cost against rivals—or even Moondrop’s cheaper offerings.

Youtube Video Summary

The MYER SL224 is a stylish tribrid (2DD + 2BA + 4 microplanars) coming in around $270, shipped with a decent 4-core cable featuring 3.5 / 4.4 / USB-C interchangeable plugs, a zipper case, and three ear-tip sets (regular silicone, SpinFit-style silicone, foam). Build is eye-catching thanks to a real mother-of-pearl faceplate; the shell is on the larger side with a universal-custom shape that sits comfortably for long sessions, though smaller ears should test fit first. Cable behavior is mostly cooperative (functional chin slider, slight memory), and overall accessories feel thoughtful for the price.

Tonally, SL224 targets a clean, clinical presentation: sub-bass carries the weight while mid-bass stays nearer to neutral, which can read a touch lean unless paired with a warmer source (tube or similar) to add body. The midrange tracks neutral until the upper-mid / lower-treble rise, boosting female vocal harmonics and air; some may find this area forward, yet it avoids the usual micro-planar harshness. Treble is well-extended and energetic, if not the smoothest—there’s a hint of disconnect around the pinna gain—but this nit shows mainly against sets two to three times the price. Technical chops are a highlight: resolution rivals class standouts (think AFUL P7 territory), imaging is tidy, stage is fairly wide, and it earns a strong nod for competitive gaming.

Against peers, CK2V hits harder down low but dips mid-bass and feels less even up top; AFUL P7 is more balanced yet less flattering to female vocals and trickier in treble; “Dusk” (DSP) delivers better bass and a warmer tilt; “Brain Dance” is flashier but far sharper; Moondrop Meteor tracks a similar tonality with smoother highs and a mid-centric lean—an easy upgrade path if this signature clicks. Recommendation is clear: pick SL224 for a mid/treble-focused set with standout detail and clarity; skip it if sensitive to upper-mid energy or chasing a warm, bass-rich tuning. For value, this feels underrated and distinct in a meta-heavy market, earning a solid three-star recommendation.