Moondrop x Crinacle Dusk VS Hercules Audio Noah

Youtube Video Summary

Build impresses out of the box: a premium case, a handsome semi-transparent shell that’s a touch larger than AFUL’s Magic One, a smaller nozzle, and excellent comfort—easy A+. The included DSP cable feels great, while the analog cable comes off a bit cheap for the price. Packaging and accessories sit at an average level overall.

In analog form, this is a Jekyll-and-Hyde situation. Channel matching is spot-on, but the presentation reads flat/neutral to a fault—solid, yet not especially competitive, fitting more a $150–$170 tier for raw value. Versus the original Blessing 2 Dusk, the new Dusk extends better up top with more air, but from bass through upper mids (to ~8 kHz) the older set still vocals better and feels more engaging; upgrading for the analog tuning alone isn’t advised. Alternatives like the PULA PA02 or CKLVX 1DD+4BA hit a similar, clean-neutral aim, while Gizaudio Chopin shows a smarter 5–6 kHz dip, livelier mids, and punchier bass at roughly half the price. Among Crin collabs, it’s clearly more refined than the Dioko, but not a slam-dunk over his other budget-minded sets.

The story flips with the DSP. Engaged, the Dusk becomes an easy recommendation: noticeably more balanced, resolving, and simply fun, earning a “perfect score for value” within the DSP lane. Caveats: Android support is the sweet spot; iPhone compatibility can be finicky, pushing some users to desktop—where manual EQ already exists. Still, the app is simple, the extra tunings are useful, and plug-and-play convenience (no dongle DAC dance) is a win. Bottom line: as an analog IEM, only “good” and overpriced; as a DSP IEM, genuinely excellent—highly worth it if the use case fits.

Youtube Video Summary

Hercules Audio Noah arrives with a premium package: a metallic, cozy shell with a secure anti-tragus catch, a gold nozzle, and a genuinely excellent 4.4 mm cable (red/black channel markers, smooth chin slider, solid Y-split). Accessories are thoughtful—tips, cleaning brush, a USB-C DAC, and a plush case—making the whole experience feel dialed-in and durable. Fit is easy, build is handsome, and the cable quality stands out as one of the better stock options at this price.

Sonically, Noah brings a vocal-forward presentation with a clean, punchy, and hard-hitting bass shelf; it’s engaging, rich, and fun. There’s a notable 1 kHz rise and energetic upper-mids that push presence, while treble stays polite—good clarity, but not the last word in sparkle/air or micro-detail. Think “audiophile-style tuning” rather than meta-neutral: more drive and dynamism than shimmer. Compared with peers, it carries some Elysian-style DNA (cleaner and more exciting than Pilgrim/Noir, less dazzling up top than Apostle/Annihilator), and versus the hyped YU9 it swaps treble dazzle for meatier bass impact, making the two strong complements.

Value depends on region: list sits around $400, but tariffs and shipping can push it above $500 in the U.S., which tempers the bang-for-buck. As a result, it’s an easy recommendation for those seeking a mid/bass-forward, vocal-centric signature—demo at a show if possible, or consider the used market for a sharper deal. Bass is a 10/10 with satisfying slam, the overall presentation is lively and majestic, and while treble finesse is merely good, the tuning’s energy and musical drive make Noah a memorable, hype-worthy listen for the right ears.

Youtube Video Summary

Hercules Audio’s Noah targets the mid-tier with a 1DD+3BA setup around $400, and the physical package impresses: a premium, crush-resistant case, Divinus Velvet ear tips, a Type-C dongle, and an all-metal black-and-gold shell that looks luxe and fits comfortably for long sessions. The four-core black cable feels solid with quality connectors and a working chin slider, even if it isn’t the softest. Sonically, the Noah aims for a fun, engaging listen via a relaxed treble, but bass hype meets reality—there’s strong sub-bass extension while mid-bass weight and texture come up short, so punch and grit aren’t at “basshead” levels.

The midrange is the star: forward enough to keep vocals clear without sounding shouty, though a slightly lean lower-mid can thin out male voices. Treble stays smooth yet extended, ideal for treble-sensitive listeners (treble-heads may want more bite). Technicalities hold their own for the price—good layering, imaging, and micro-detail, with a soundstage that’s a touch above average. Versus the YU9/CH it’s smoother and more fun (that set is brighter and more clinical), while Dusk Analog (DSP) runs warmer with bass some may prefer but even more laid-back mids/treble; for a true bass fix, Kiwi Ears Punch remains a go-to. Overall, Noah is enjoyable with standout build and accessories, best for those who like sub-bass focus + relaxed treble; tuning quirks keep it from a higher nod, settling on a two-star recommendation for value.

Youtube Video Summary

The new Moondrop x Crinacle Dusk borrows the Blessing 3’s ergonomics and accessory spread—spring tips, a lightweight 3.5 mm cable, and a braided USB DSP cable—while switching to a tribrid driver array: 2DD for bass, 2BA for mids, and 2 micro-planars for treble. The shell is medium-large yet secure and comfortable, with a narrower nozzle than earlier Blessings and a cleaner faceplate design. The DSP cable can sweeten tonality, but there are caveats: occasional artifacts, spotty DAP compatibility, and an Android-only app with EQ limits (no tweaks below ~60 Hz or above ~10 kHz).

On the analog cable, tonality lands neutral and mid-centric with a tasteful sub-bass lift and slightly eased presence region—still a touch clinical, but now with added body and engagement. The star is the bass quality: tight, punchy, and tactile without masking the mids. Imaging/separation are clearly above average, and treble has better extension and metallic timbre than older Moondrops. Swapping to the DSP cable warms the mids and adds a bit of mid-bass punch (less brightness, richer tone), trading a hint of separation for extra smoothness.

Comparisons: vs OG Dusk, the new set’s bass is less blammy but higher quality, and the treble timbre is more realistic; vs Blessing 3, this is fuller, deeper, and less thin; vs Hype 4, stage width and bass quantity favor the Hype, but the Dusk keeps vocals cleaner and more balanced. DSP experiments show Blessing 3 + DSP can get very close to the Dusk’s FR, and even the budget Moondrop May narrows the gap—yet the Dusk still wins on bass tightness, treble refinement, and overall technical polish. As an analog IEM around $360, this is the one to beat—an easy 5/5.

Youtube Video Summary

Stock tuning lands in the safe-and-smooth lane: a gently warm balance with a slight treble emphasis, nothing egregious and nothing especially standout. It works well for J-pop/K-pop at mid volume thanks to tamed upper-mids that keep sibilance in check. The trade-off is softer, “vanilla” vocals that miss the last bit of extension, air, and micro-detail; turn it up for more presence and the treble gets spicy—not helped by unit variance that can throw a 16k peak. Cymbal detail is decent with minimal “planar timbre,” but it can get a touch sizzly.

Against the field, Dusk struggles to justify the premium. Truthear Nova plays the same all-rounder role for much less while feeling more open up top; want a bit more top-end than Nova, there’s the Chopin at ~$200. Hype 4 comes off as a more well-rounded Dusk—better low-end texture, a hint more vocal reach, and less sharpness—and Quintet delivers a similar idea for cheaper. Even with EQ in the mix, Blessing 3 can match or better the result (smoother treble, no channel imbalance). Net: the sound is good but not special, and the value calculus isn’t favorable.

The supposed differentiator—DSP—isn’t it. The app feels unstable (settings not applying, frequent crashes), Android-only for adjustments, and awkward with external DAC/amps where EQ may not pass through. There’s a minor noise floor between pauses. Of the presets, “Stock 3.5mm (Analog)” and Bass+ are the only keepers; “Stock USB” is warmer but needs more upper-mids, and the Diffuse Field Tilt lands awkwardly. Phone amps also bottleneck staging; better sources open it up—but then the DSP conflicts. Add in QC concerns, and the verdict is clear: a pleasant, inoffensive listen, yet overhyped and overpriced for what it delivers; a solid sub-$200 proposition, not at its current bracket.

Youtube Video Summary

Moondrop x Crinacle Dusk earns raves for music: a clean, textured, fast low end with real sub-bass punch that avoids bloat, a natural, resolving midrange for male/female vocals and instruments, and crisp, well-controlled treble that delivers cymbal air without harshness. The overall presentation feels well-rounded and technical enough to spar with sets far above its price, evoking “revisit the whole library” vibes. Build and comfort impress too—lightweight shell, transparent chassis with a wood-like carbon faceplate, and an ergonomic fit. Tip-rolling matters: Spring Tips add a touch of openness and air, while SpinFit W1 tightens stage and teases out more bass on the “fish-mouth” nozzle.

Accessories are solid: a standard 3.5 mm cable plus a USB-C DSP cable that’s great for Android/iPad on-the-go listening, though PC gaming revealed instability in some titles (stutters/freezes in Apex Legends and Call of Duty). Day to day, the cable’s braid resists tangles, and the included case/tips round out a tidy package.

For competitive play, performance is mixed. Imaging is good and the bass gives an immersive punch, but the stage skews intimate and heavy effects can mask subtle cues. In Apex Legends, verticality and depth perception suffer—overhead action blends at forehead level, distant slides/grass shuffles fade, and chaotic fights cause layering to mush before quickly recovering. Call of Duty shows similar trade-offs with aerial and fine details under bombardment, while Valorant fares best thanks to tighter maps and fewer simultaneous effects (though horizontal peeks and micro-depth could still be sharper). The takeaway: S-tier for music in this bracket and a fun, cinematic gamer, but not the most surgical pick for top-ranked competitive play.